In short
- Side by side describes how the two eyes are packed into one frame.
- Fisheye describes how the lens mapped the world onto the sensor.
- A typical adult VR scene is both: fisheye projection, side-by-side stereo.
- Three players name lens profiles; five document fisheye in some form.
They are not alternatives
A VR video file has a stereo layout and a projection, and they are independent. Side by side, written SBS or tagged _LR, means the left eye's image occupies the left half of the frame and the right eye's the right half. Over-under, tagged _TB, stacks them instead. That is the stereo layout, and it says nothing about how either image was captured.
Fisheye describes the lens. A fisheye lens compresses the edges of the scene and stretches the centre, packing a very wide angle onto a flat sensor. Playing that back correctly requires undoing the same mapping, which is why a player needs to know not just that a file is fisheye but which lens produced it.
Almost every modern adult VR scene is both: shot on a wide fisheye lens, delivered as a side-by-side stereo pair. The labels sit next to each other in the file name for exactly that reason.
What goes wrong with each
Get the stereo layout wrong and the symptom is unmistakable: you see two of everything, or the depth inverts and your eyes refuse to merge the image. The fix is one setting, and all eight players in this guide offer it.
Get the projection wrong and the symptom is subtler, which is why it goes unnoticed for longer. The scene looks flat in the middle and stretched at the edges, the performer seems slightly wrong in a way people usually blame on the studio, and nothing is obviously broken. That is a fisheye file played as plain equirectangular video.
Which players name the lens
HereSphere publishes the convention in its FAQ and supports named profiles: fisheye at 180 degrees with a linear lens, MKX200, MKX220, VRCA220 and RF52. DeoVR documents fisheye at 180, 190 and 200 degrees with MKX lens correction plus 220. Pigasus auto-detects the same tags from file names. SKYBOX lists VR180, 360, 200 and 220 degree content, and PLAY'A and Moon VR Player name fisheye in their feature lists without naming profiles.
4XVR and Prism VR do not mention fisheye on any official page.
Which studios say what they shoot
Three of seventeen state fisheye support: SexLikeReal, POVR and RealJamVR, the last of which also documents interactive scripts and passthrough. Everyone else leaves the lens unstated, which makes the file name the only clue and makes keeping it intact important.
Side-by-side is stated by sixteen of seventeen as part of their 3D support.
Reading a file name
The convention is widely shared and rarely documented, except by HereSphere. In broad terms: _180 or _360 is the projection angle, _LR, _RL, _TB and _BT are stereo layouts, _F180 or _180F marks a fisheye linear lens, and _MKX200, _MKX220, _VRCA220 and _RF52 name specific camera lenses.
Rename the file and your player loses all of it, which is the most common self-inflicted playback problem in this hobby. If you organise a library, keep the original name in the file and put your organisation in the folder structure.
Why studios use fisheye at all
Field of view. A rectilinear lens that covered 200 degrees would be impractical, and the wider the angle the more the edges of a rectilinear image stretch. A fisheye lens accepts a known, correctable distortion in exchange for an enormous field of view on a reasonable sensor, which is exactly the trade a VR camera wants to make.
The cost is that playback has to undo the mapping, and that only works if the player knows which mapping was used. Different lens makers produce different curves, which is why HereSphere lists four named profiles rather than one fisheye setting. A scene shot on an MKX200 and played with a VRCA220 profile will be slightly wrong in a way that is hard to name and easy to feel.
If you cannot work out which is which
- Look at the frame on a flat screen first. If you see two near-identical images next to each other, it is side by side. Stacked vertically, it is over-under.
- Look at the shape of each half. A circular or heavily curved image with dark corners is fisheye. A rectangle that fills the half evenly is equirectangular.
- Check the file name for tags before you rename anything.
- In the player, fix the stereo layout first and the projection second. Stereo errors are obvious, so you will know immediately when that part is right.
What this means when you buy
If you subscribe to a studio that shoots on wide lenses and your player does not name profiles, you are seeing a slightly wrong version of what you paid for. That is a thirty-dollar problem with a thirty-dollar solution, and it is the clearest reason anyone in this market upgrades from a free player to a paid one.
Our side-by-side page and fisheye page go through each one on its own, with the tags each player recognises and the studios that state what they shoot.
Is fisheye better than side by side?
The question does not apply: one is a lens projection and the other a stereo layout. A typical scene is fisheye and side by side at the same time.
Why does my scene look stretched at the edges?
A fisheye file is being played as plain equirectangular video. Set the projection in your player, or use one that reads the lens tag from the file name.
Why do I see two images?
The player is treating a side-by-side frame as a single flat image. Switch the stereo setting to side by side.
Which player handles fisheye best?
HereSphere, because it lets you name the lens rather than relying on detection. DeoVR and Pigasus document their own detection and cover most files.
Other head-to-heads are in the comparisons index.